Buttery Shrimp Rolls

60 minutes

super easy

serves 6

If someone asked me what dishes absolutely define summer, lobster rolls would be at the very top of that list, if not, the top. Well, today we aren’t making lobster rolls (sorry! you can use lobster meat in this recipe, though!) but we are finding a way to use our good, reliable friend shrimp in the place of our very expensive friend, lobster.

This recipe is extremely easy. It’s actually inspired by an even easier family recipe that my grandmother, who grew up in Maine, introduced to my family back in the day. The original recipe is lobster meat tossed in Hellmans mayo (my grandmother specifically chose Hellmans because some other mayos are sweeter) and then put onto a hamburger roll and cooked in a skillet in a bath of butter, similar to the way you would cook a grilled cheese. That’s it. That’s the recipe. I grew up eating these every summer and would throw back up to 3-4 in one sitting. They are just THAT GOOD. Considering my family has Maine roots, you may be surprised that these are kind of a fusion between Connecticut and Maine style lobster rolls. I’m not surprised at all because they’re taking the best of bothh worlds and hot damn, it shows!!!!

buttery shrimp lobster rolls with tarragon and scallions

My goal with this recipe was to get this same level of deliciousness, but with shrimp meat instead. It’s rare I will go out and buy lobster meat, and our NYC grocery store (cough Food Cellar, cough) is outrageously expensive. On the other hand, we always have frozen shrimp in the house because its pretty affordable for a large quantity. When cooked properly, shrimp can have a similar level of tenderness and butteriness as a lobster tail. Of course, we aren’t getting the claw meat and that cherished knuckle meat, but I promise these sandwiches will taste so good that you won’t even notice.

5 from 7 Reviews


Adjust Servings
3 1/2cups shrimp
1/3cup mayonnaise
1/8tsp salt
1 tbsp melted butter
2tsp dried tarragon
1/2tsp lemon juice
1/4cup chopped scallions
6 hamburger buns
2tbsp unsalted butter, for pan
Oil, for pan



Fill a large pot with water on the stove. Salt the water generously and bring it to a boil.

Mark as complete

As the water is coming to a boil, peel and clean the shrimp. Save the shells to boil with the shrimp. (they add a lot of flavor!) To devein the shrimp, use a pairing knife. Place the blade of the knife on the top (thicker end) of the shrimp and put it in the center, along the line on the back of the shrimp. Slice the back of the shrimp, starting at the top and going all the way down. Cut only 1/8th of the way through the shrimp. The goal is to skim the top and reveal the shrimp's digestive track. After you slcie through, you should see a brown line-- that's the digestive tract. Don't worry, it's just full of sand! Remove it and repeat with all of the shrimp.

Mark as complete

Once the water is boiling, place the shrimp in the water and allow them to boil. If they are fresh, check on them after one minute. If they are opaque, remove them from the boiling water and place them into an ice bath, or put them in a bowl and run cold water over the bowl until the shrimp cool down. If your shrimp were frozen, boil for 2-3 minutes, until opaque. It's important to keep an eye on the shrimp's color so that they don't overcook! We want them to be tender and juicy just like lobster meat!

Mark as complete

While the shrimp is cooling, place the mayo, melted butter, tarragon, salt, lemon juice and 3 tbsp of scallions into a bowl and mix until combined.

Mark as complete

Remove the cooled shrimp from the bowl and place on a cutting board. Cut each shrimp to your liking for your shrimp rolls. I personally like to cut them into thirds, with some larger and smaller pieces because I like to have texture contrast ini the sandwich. This is a personal preference, so trust your gut! Taste the mixture to see if you want to adjust any other flavors.

Mark as complete

Add the cooled shrimp to the mayo mixture and toss until fully coated. If you want more mayo, feel free to add more.

Mark as complete

With a spoon or washed hands, sandwich some of the shrimp mixture in between hamburger buns. You don't want to overflow the sandwich because we are searing and flipping it in a pan, but add as much as you can. Repeat with all of the sandwiches.

Mark as complete

Heat a skillet over medium heat. Add 2 tbsp and splash of oil to a pan. (The oil isn't necessary, but it does help prevent the butter from burning off of the pan and drying up quickly.)

Mark as complete

Once the pan is hot, add as many sandwiches that you can to the skillet and let them sear for 1-2 minutes, until golden brown. Press the sandwich down with the back of your spatula to get that bread to soak in alllll that butter! 

Mark as complete

Flip the sandwiches and sear the other side. The second side usually browns more quickly since there will be burnt butter deposits in the pan, so sear it for about 1 minute, or until browned to your liking. 

Mark as complete

Plate the sandwiches and sprinkle some more scallions around the plate because it's beautiful and delicious to have more scallions 😀 (this is optional, of course.) Serve immediately!
Mark as complete



  • Maria

    5 stars
    Genuinely shocked how similar these are to lobster rolls and dare I say they may be better?! So good!!!!

  • JDH

    What are your thoughts about subs for mayo? Trying to minimize fat intake…

  • web hosting company

    Very descriptive blog, I loved that a lot. Will there
    be a part 2?

  • best web hosting

    I love what you guys are up too. This sort of clever work and
    coverage! Keep up the excellent works guys I’ve
    added you guys to our blogroll.

  • adreamoftrains web hosting service

    What’s up everyone, it’s my first go to see at this
    web site, and piece of writing is truly fruitful
    in favor of me, keep up posting these posts. adreamoftrains web hosting services

  • best web hosting company

    Its like you read my mind! You appear to know so much about this, like
    you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you could do with some pics
    to drive the message home a little bit, but instead of that, this is fantastic blog.
    A fantastic read. I’ll certainly be back.

  • web hosting reviews

    My family members all the time say that I am killing my time here at web, however I know I am getting knowledge daily by reading
    such fastidious posts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

[instagram-feed user="easymealstheme6" num=10 cols=10 showfollow= false showheader=false imagepadding=0]